Week 10 Blog Post

In my opinion, the first film played much more into Western genre than the second. For example, the acting is extremely dramatized in Django, whereas it is much more subdued in the Sukiyaki version. Also, the character of Django is must more aloof and disconnected than the Gunman of the second film, which is exactly how the anti-hero of a Western is usually portrayed. The Japanese film was very stylized and seemed much more modern than the 1966 film.

Even though I think that Django was more faithful to the Western genre, the Japanese version obviously stayed true in some ways as well. In both movies, the plot was set in a desolate town where its residents are warring against one another. Also, many, many guns are used in both films, as per usual with a Western, though the Japanese film also incorporates swords which give a more elegant feel than the wilder, chaotic original. Color plays such a vital role and communicates messages in both films as well, with red representing one side of the battle, white representing the other and black showing that Django/the Gunman are not necessarily the knights in shining armor that we as an audience might expect in a protagonist.

The thing that stuck with me the most was how the second film so obviously presented a critique of the first film in the way that women are treated. In the first movie, women are objectified, smacked around, and referred to as “anyone’s”. They are damsels in distress who only “feel like a real woman” when the anti-hero rescues them. In the second movie however, women are portrayed with an absolute strength as opposed to helpless or even as quiet bystanders. One of the female leads saw her husband shot multiple times and killed and yet was depicted as strong and capable at the time of the film’s events. The older woman was even bolder, shooting and killing many of the bad guys with the same skill level as men in either film. I think this really reflects a world more accepting of women being as powerful, strong and skilled as men.


One thought on “Week 10 Blog Post

  1. When it comes to the western genre, there are certainly a bunch of parallels between both films. However, I also noticed that both Django and Sukiyaki Western Django also had a lot of similarities with Yojimbo and Fistful of Dollars. For starters, the plot of all four movies was about an outsider who came to desolated town run by two clashing entities. All four movies also have a damsel in distress of the sort and the dark, shady protagonist seems to have to overcome some sort of adversity as well, usually in the case of him getting hurt. Finally, there is the all to famous showdown that each movie delivers at its highest tension. Nevertheless, each film has its own nuances that certainly make them unique from other westerns. As you already stated, Sukiyaki definitely gives a higher and stronger role to its female casts members than the other films do. Made in 2007, perhaps this was because of modern times and a portrayal of how women are seen today. Ultimately, there are countless examples in each film but the unifying factor of all of them is that at their core, they are all just “good ole westerns”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s